top of page


Prices start at $39.00 per baker's dozen.

Ask anyone who has had the pleasure of experiencing one of these sweet treats, and they will most assuredly tell you "they are absolutely the best!" Handcrafted in small batches and always made to order. Each selection more incredible than last. Perfect for gift giving or to keep all to yourself!
This is what heaven is all about.
*Cookie Juniors and SuperCookies™ also available -

call for details.


The Original™
Our very own, amazing double chocolate chip cookie with walnuts

*Our cornerstone cookie has welcomed cabin guests at The Kickapoo Valley Ranch in Southwestern Wisconsin for over a decade. This cookie's popularity grew along with our lodging business and is the reason that Cowboy David's Cookies are now available to the general public. We've lavished this cookie with the most generous portions of two kinds of chocolate chips, with chunky walnuts and a whole lotta attitude! To know this cookie is to know what heaven is really all about!


 Molasses cookie with a "twist"

*Old fashioned? Not so much! This cookie presents a comfortable, easily recognizable spice-filled profile, yet kicked up a notch with a delightful punch of citrus! And it is important to note that all of this delicious goodness comes to you 100% dairy-free and with no nuts.


Triple chocolate chip cookie without nuts
*Everything that our "Original" possesses (the rich & abundant milk & white chocolate chips, etc... )but this time without the nuts and this one has an extra chocolate chunk! Recently revamped to improve it's overall appearance & quality!!

A classic!!!


Oatmeal raisin caramel apple cookie

*Comfort cookie best describes this complex, multi-flavored treat. Everything you'd expect - raisins, walnuts, whole grain oatmeal and then this classic cookie heads off in whole new amazing direction with the introduction of apples & caramel. With all these wholesome ingredients you'd almost be convinced that three or four is simply healthy eating!


The Double Chocolate Chip Dark

*Our Original™ Double Chocolate Chip with Nuts REINVENTED yet again!!!
This time, we've taken our cornerstone cookie and pulled out the milk & white chocolate chips. We've replaced them with rich, high-end, dark chocolate chips and semi-sweet chunks! And you will still find an abundance of walnuts. A whole new kind of heaven!!!


Peanut butter salted caramel toffee

*A classic fork-pressed peanut butter cookie given the Cowboy David treatment!
We've added extra chocolate and toffee bits throughout and topped it off with a soft caramel that melts gloriously and then given it a sprinkle of sea salt. Nostalgic, but over-the-top for sure!

pb salted caramel.JPEG


Spiced pumpkin cranberry pecan

*Fall flavors, creatively combined!
We start this cookie with a soft, spiced pumpkin cookie base and add the tangy twist of cranberries. Pecan pieces are prevalent throughout. We then finish it off with a perfect pecan half and a sprinkle of course ground Turbinado sugar. Autumnal joy!

cranberry pumpkin cookies


Chocolate triple chocolate chip
with walnuts

*An exciting new twist on our Original™ chocolate chip cookie! This time we start with a chocolate cookie base and add the three chocolates from our No Nut cookie - milk and white chocolate chips and Semi-sweet chocolate chunks. And no chocolate chip cookie is complete without an abundance of crushed walnut pieces. A new favorite!

Choc Triple Chip_edited.jpg


Rocky road nutty chocolate chip

*Another awesome new addition to our chocolate chip coolie collection. Do a google search and you will find that half the rocky road recipes contain walnuts and half contain almonds. We figured LET'S INCLUDE BOTH!!! It's a unique and nutty combination that go great with semi-sweet chocolate and delightful mini-marshmallows.
Fun will be had by all!

Rocky Road Nutty Chip_edited.jpg


Spiced macadamia
white chocolate chip cookie

*The new chocolate chip cookie flavors keep coming! This combination is spectacular! We start off with a unique blend of spices and extracts - ginger, nutmeg, vanilla, and even rum! We also let the nuts and chocolate take center stage with a ton of Macadamia nuts and white chocolate chips. You are going to love this new gem!!!

Macadamia White Chip.JPEG


Coconut oaty pecan
double chocolate chip cookie

*To round out our new chocolate chip cookie explosion, we've come up with this amazing &  creative combination of ingredients! We started off with our perfect chocolate chip combination - white & milk, then added in pecans, coconut, and golden raisins! But, to take it right over the top, the awesome addition of oats! Folks are loving this delightful addition to our collection!!!

Oaty Pecan 2x Chip.jpeg


 The Peanut Butter Turtle™ cookie

*The combination of flavors presented here - milk chocolate, caramel, pecans & peanut butter, topped by a sprinkle of course ground sea salt AND a rich chocolate drizzle, makes this cookie an event not to be missed! If you are looking for one of the best cookies, ever - this might just be it!!!


The Chocolate Coma cookie

FIVE TIMES the chocolate joy!
*Imagine biting into a dark chocolate brownie cookie infused with espresso coffee and coming across dark & milk chocolate chips and semi-sweet chocolate chunks. And then turn the cookie around for an over-the-top taste treat since we've dipped it in a generous "dunk" of smooth dark chocolate. Like nothing you've ever tasted before, this is truly a chocolate lovers dream come true! (No nuts.)


Raspberry red velvet cookie with white chocolate

*Ask around & most folks will tell you they love red velvet cake. So we've turned it on its ear & taken it right over the top! Red velvet chocolate & fresh raspberries make up this deep, dark, moist & delicious cookie. And to perfect it we've even dipped it in white chocolate. No nuts. Extraordinary!


Caramel milk chocolate swirl cookie

*A rich, double chocolate chip cookie with an explosion of caramel throughout. Topped with a sprinkle of sea salt and a generous swirl of milk chocolate!!! This gem has no nuts.


The Bomb chocolate cookie

*An all new chocolate cookie with an explosion of white chocolate chips & semi-sweet chunks, with an undertone of coffee and then...

BAM!!! A zing of cherry and no nuts.

Topped off with a swirl of white chocolate!

It's "The Bomb" - as in cherry bomb!!!

(See what we did there!?!?!?!!!!!!!!) ;)


The Ultimate™
Our very own, amazing double chocolate chip cookie with walnuts (The Original™) DIPPED!

*Our cornerstone cookie, The Original™ Double Chocolate Chip Cookie with Walnuts, dipped in rich, high end chocolate! We've taken the best and made it even BESTER! Cowboy David himself even thinks this might just be the BESTEST cookie EVER!


Smoked sea salt dark chocolate chip pistachio cookie

*As "foodie" as a cookie can get! This one is completely over the top! We start with our classic chocolate chip cookie dough and pack in tons of super dark, gourmet chocolate chips and semi-sweet chocolate chunks. Then we add in a generous helping of coconut and rough crushed pistachios.  What really takes it over the top are the unique spices - cardamom, ground mace, and a generous sprinkle of smoked sea salt. To finish it all off we dip it in dark chocolate and add a garnish of pistachios and that incredible sea salt.
This cookie is absolutely an event!!!

dark choc pistachio.JPEG


The Triumph™
The double chocolate chip cookie with walnuts (The Original™) SWIRLED... WITH AN EXTRA, SPECIAL GIFT!

*How can you make the bestest cookie, ever, even better? It is oh so very simple:
ADD BACON. Yes. Add bacon!!!!! This cookie

is perfection - milk & white chocolates, walnuts, more chocolate swirled on top, and non-nitrite uncured bacon throughout and sprinkled on the chocolate swirl.
Oh. My. Gawd!!!

Triumph wide.JPG


The Christmas Coma cookie

*Just like our Chocolate Coma™ but all wrapped up for the holidays!
Here again we have a dark chocolate brownie cookie infused with espresso coffee and packed with dark & milk chocolate chips and semi-sweet chocolate chunks. This time, though, we've
a hint of peppermint & dipped it in a generous "dunk" of smooth dark chocolate or white chocolate and an added sprinkle of peppermint candy crunch. A chocolate lovers Christmas dream come true! (No nuts.)


Orange Cranberry Enchantment cookie

*This cookie is an instant winner!
The perfect combination of orange, cranberry, almonds, and an amazing spice mix make this sour cream cookie the centerpiece of any holiday dessert table. We've then added a generous white chocolate swirt and a sparkle of white sanding sugar.
An unbelievable amount of joy for one & all!   

The Alternatives Collection

All our cookies are now available

*Our Alternatives Collection cookies are just as incredible as their originals! Now, all of them are available gluten-free. Every last one!!!
Check out the SHOPPING PAGE for the alternate pricing.
*Dairy, eggs, & sugar are still present.

****PLEASE NOTE: Our Molasses Cookie with a Twist is also DAIRY FREE!

bottom of page